Changing the Game: Set the Table Before You Negotiate

Welcome to the first edition of "Changing the Game," a newsletter by me, Roberto Ordonez, a seasoned negotiation expert and the Managing Partner of Alkimya Catalyst. With over 20 years of experience advising complex negotiations, I specialize in guiding corporations, governments, startups, and family businesses through complex strategic negotiations and conflict resolution. As a professor at esteemed universities like Georgetown, Northwestern, ESCP, and HULT, I am passionate about sharing my knowledge of principled negotiation and collaborative problem-solving. My mission is to empower negotiators to create value through strategic preparation and effective engagement, helping them navigate the intricacies of human dynamics to achieve win-win outcomes.


Dear Savvy Negotiator,


Do you think your negotiation starts at the table? …. Think again!


In my over two decades of experience in high-stakes negotiations, I've learned that the game is often won well before you seat at the negotiation table. Today, I'm going to share with you the art of "setting the table" - a crucial yet often overlooked aspect of negotiation preparation.


The Power of Setting the Table


Before you step into any negotiation, you need to "set the table". Why? Because most of the game is won before you sit on the negotiation table.


And I am going to tell you how you can do it:


1. Right Parties:  Have you included all the key Players?

It's not just about who's in from of you at the table. Have you identified and included all relevant players (decision makers, influencers, implementers, and even blockers). Missing a critical voice can unravel everything later. 


Insight: In a recent negotiation with a government, we failed to identify an outside player who was going to be negatively impacted by the outcome of the negotiation and had direct line of influence over the decision maker. This overlook nearly derailed the entire deal. 


2. Right Sequence: Choreograph your moves - Work backwards from your desired outcome.

Ask yourself: "What needs to happen, and who needs to be on board?"

Success is often about getting the timing and order just right.


Insight: While advising a family business Board, we realized that in order to get the Chairman to consider our proposal we needed to get some relevant family members on board first. And, in order to get these family members on board, we needed to get some of their advisors on board first. Skipping any of these steps would have resulted in a negotiation failure. 


3. Right Issues: Uncover hidden value - Don't leave value on the table.

Have you considered every possible issue?

This includes hidden and side issues that might not be obvious at first glance but could add significant value.


Insight: In a procurement negotiation a few years ago we were deadlocked over price. We decided to dig deeper into the constraints they had. Transportation cost was identified as a key cost driver for them. The scale of my client allowed them to have preferential shipping costs. Understanding this limitation allow us to help the vendor reduce their shipping cost which in turn allow them to lower their price. 


4. Right Interests: Beyond positions - Do you truly understand your counterpart's motivations?

Often, these interests remain unspoken until you ask the right questions.

Dig deep to discover what they really care about.


Insight: I teach my EMBA students to always ask "Why?" at least five times. It's amazing what you uncover when you keep digging.


5. Right Consequences: Know Your BATNA … and Theirs

Always ask what happens to them if you say no?

Understand the impact of your decisions on the other party. A well-timed "no" can be a powerful tool if you know the consequences it creates for them.


Insight: In one large transaction with a party that was much bigger than us in size, we uncovered the expensive consequences to them of not negotiation with us and instead making a deal with any of their other alternatives. This strengthened our position immensely. 


The Power of Preparation

If you get to the table with all the pieces already set, you've played much of the game in advance. Negotiations without this groundwork can feel like being in a straitjacket—restricted and limited.


This Week's Challenge

Before your next negotiation, I challenge you to:


1. Spend at least a couple of hours "setting the table".  Ask yourself: do I have the right parties, issues, interests, and sequence? Are the consequences well understood by them? 


2. Identify one stakeholder you might have overlooked and consider their potential impact.


3. Brainstorm three hidden issues that could create unexpected value.


Remember, thorough preparation isn't just about preparing strong arguments — it's about creating value and building lasting relationships. By mastering the art of "setting the table," you're not just preparing for a negotiation; you're changing the game entirely.


So, do you "set the table" before negotiating? Or do you jump straight in, only to find there's little room left to maneuver?


Until next time, keep sharpening those negotiation skills!


Best regards,

Roberto Ordonez

Negotiation Strategist and Founder, Alkimya Catalyst


P.S. If you found this newsletter helpful, consider resharing and follow me for more strategies that elevate your negotiation game.